Electric cars are becoming more popular in India. As petrol and diesel prices continue to rise, many people are looking for eco-friendly and affordable electric vehicles (EVs). In 2025, three major options in the entry-level EV market are the Tata Punch EV, Citroen eC3, and MG Comet EV. All three offer something unique, but which one is the best for you? Let’s compare them in simple words.
1. Tata Punch EV Design & Looks
Tata Punch EV looks bold and sporty. It is built on Tata’s new EV platform and resembles the petrol Punch but with some modern EV styling like a closed front grille and LED lighting. It looks more like a proper SUV.
Citroen eC3 is a hatchback with a crossover design. It has funky looks, a high bonnet, and bold color options. It gives a youthful and modern vibe.
MG Comet EV is the smallest of the three. It has a very compact and boxy design, perfect for city driving. Its size makes it easy to park, but it might not appeal to everyone because of its quirky design.
Verdict: For stylish looks and SUV feel, Tata Punch EV wins. For compact city driving, MG Comet EV is good. For unique and funky design, Citroen eC3 is best.
2. Interior & Features
Tata Punch EV comes with a large touchscreen (10.25-inch), digital instrument cluster, automatic climate control, wireless charging, and a good-quality interior. It feels premium for its price.
Citroen eC3 has a simpler cabin. It offers a 10.2-inch touchscreen, manual AC, and connected car features. The quality is decent but not as premium.
MG Comet EV has a modern cabin with two screens (10.25-inch each) – one for infotainment and one for the driver display. It also includes voice control, wireless Android Auto/Apple CarPlay, and other smart features.
Verdict: Tata Punch EV is ahead in terms of features and quality. MG Comet is tech-friendly, while Citroen eC3 is basic but functional.
3. Battery & Range
| Car | Battery Capacity | Claimed Range (ARAI) |
| Tata Punch EV | 25 kWh / 35 kWh | 315 – 421 km |
| Citroen eC3 | 29.2 kWh | 320 km |
| MG Comet EV | 17.3 kWh | 230 km |
Tata Punch EV offers two battery options. The larger one offers the best range in this segment. Citroen eC3 has a slightly smaller range. MG Comet EV has the least range but is suitable for city driving.
Verdict: For longer range and highway use, Tata Punch EV is best. For city commutes, MG Comet EV works fine. eC3 sits in the middle.
4. Charging Time
- Tata Punch EV supports fast charging and can charge 10-80% in around 56 minutes (with DC charger).
- Citroen eC3 also supports fast charging and takes around 57 minutes for 10-80%.
- MG Comet EV takes longer since it does not have DC fast charging. Full charge via regular charger takes about 7 hours.
Verdict: Tata Punch EV and Citroen eC3 are better in charging speed.
5. Driving Experience
Tata Punch EV has a powerful motor and feels strong while driving. It handles well, even on rough roads.
Citroen eC3 has a smooth drive but feels a bit slower compared to the Punch.
MG Comet EV is designed mainly for city use. It’s very small and easy to drive in traffic but lacks power for highways.
Verdict: For a balanced and confident drive, Tata Punch EV is the winner.
6. Price (Ex-showroom, 2025)
| Car | Starting Price |
| Tata Punch EV | ₹10.99 lakh |
| Citroen eC3 | ₹11.50 lakh |
| MG Comet EV | ₹6.99 lakh |
MG Comet EV is the cheapest but has limited space and range. Tata Punch EV gives more value for money with more features and better range.
Verdict: MG Comet EV is budget-friendly, but Tata Punch EV offers the best overall package.
Final Verdict Which One is Best?
Buy Tata Punch EV if you want:
- Best driving range
- SUV styling
- Premium features
- Value for money
Buy Citroen eC3 if you want:
- A unique design
- Decent range
- French car brand appeal
Buy MG Comet EV if you want:
- A budget EV for short city rides
- Compact size
- Smart features for the price
Conclusion
All three EVs – Tata Punch EV, Citroen eC3, and MG Comet EV – serve different needs. If you’re looking for a stylish, long-range EV with many features, Tata Punch EV is the best choice. If you want something more compact and affordable for the city, MG Comet EV makes sense. For a quirky design with decent specs, Citroen eC3 fits well.